Will Palestinians face the fate of American Indians?

By Labib Taha*


Considering the Palestinian cause from one angle, it seems to be in the most difficult situation since the emergence of the Palestinian tragedy more than a hundred years ago. The dangers that face the Palestinian people represented in attempts towards making the political division between the West Bank and Gaza permanent, confiscating the remaining land of the Palestinians for the colonialists and their projects, and liquidating the refugee issue by decreasing the financing of UNRWA. Everything is being plotted nowadays against the Palestinians by the United States, Israel and their allies who also serve this plot.

The above mentioned dangers facing the Palestinian entity, whether cultural, social or demographic; mean the futility of the Palestinian struggle over decades that has been and continues to be one of its goals the repatriation of refugees to their homeland

The Palestinian division is another calamity that may not be less than the Nakba that took place in 1948. Otherwise, how can a boat sail in a very delicate and dangerous set of circumstances if it has more than one commander? The leadership in perfectly normal circumstances requires exceptional skills and abilities, so what to do if the circumstances are blurred!

The third aspect of the dangers is the loss of the Palestinian people to its land and its resources, there is no people in the world in the nowadays its land has been confiscated except the Palestinian people, the holder of the long-lasting tragedy. When we talk about the land, we do not forget the symbolic, cultural, political and economic meanings of the city of Jerusalem. The occupation has been Judaizing it, as well as the rest of the Palestinian lands with its endless housing projects, as if the occupation if facing a population explosion.

We return to the question, which is the title of the article. Do Palestinians face the fate of the American Indians? Israel and those who back it up see that the solution to the Palestinian tragedy is to oppress the Palestinian people and subjugate it by various means; the goal will be to accept what the rulers of Israel, its generals and orientalists are planning.

The American Indians are the indigenous people of the United States. The fate of the American Indians resembles the Palestinian people; colonizers invade their homeland, dispossess the original citizens of their land and committed massacres against them to establish their "state". The newcomers build their life and colonial civilization at the expense of the simple people who are now living on the sidelines of American life.

As an introduction to answering this question, Munir Al-Akash, in his book "A Palestinian State for the Red Indians", cited a saying by the Red Indian leader Tecumseh in September 1811, when he said that Red Indian have only to resist or wait for genocide. The were stronger than the White invader, but they will not be able to resist them if the white man can divide the Indians.

The American Indians were defeated, according to Al-Akash, due to the peaceful spirit and beliefs of these peoples and for other reasons.

The lesson of the American Indian resistance is clear and needs no comment, and a people like the Palestinian people who refuse to be annihilated for more than a century deserve not to face the fate of the American Indians. Nevertheless, the choice of Palestinians for unity or separation remains the defining factor for what Palestinians will face in the coming days.


* A Palestinian journalist based in Ramallah





The Liberum

Vox Populi, Vox Dei
See full bio >
The Liberum runs on your donation. Fight with us for a free society.
Donation Form (#6)

One comment on “Will Palestinians face the fate of American Indians?”

  1. You people are quite literally mentally ill. EVERYTHING is about YOU, somehow. The worst thing that could possibly happen in life is the appearance of some new people who were actually friendly and actually willing to build up the country together, and it is a "disaster". You just can't stand to be made stupid looking, and your people did very little and obviously feel the worst of Arab feelings, which is SHAME.

    For the love of God I do not know why, you have nothing to be ashamed of in comparison with anyone else or their progress and abilities, but you might be ashamed of the Arab mental illness on display here, or smashing children's heads in with hammers, dissecting women body parts and other acts of "resistance" and "liberation":


    here's a hint: the American Indians are not the "indigenous people of the United States", they were the aboriginal race of North AMERICA. The Uited States was created by the WHITES, just as "palestine" was invented by the WEST, not the Arabs. The idea that some people are "indigenous" and others merely "foreign" is xenophobic to the point of insanity. Palestine is your country to LIVE in, not to KILL others or keep them out. It is a universal inheritance not a tribal territory, and you are not some "tribe" of people that owns the land as a group. YOU ARE NOT A GROUP, outside of your own history itself, which might go back to 1830 at most.

More articles you might like

- by Hiba Kilany on 12/07/2024

Hypocrisy at its best

We are living in a hypocritical world… Something isn’t right. Let me tell you why. […]
- - by The Liberum on 06/07/2024

On the Path to Armenia-Azerbaijan Reconciliation

Azerbaijan and Armenia moved closer to peace since Azerbaijan re-established political control over its whole […]

Petro preferences – A ‘novel’ way to answer lingering questions

The story is semi-science fiction set in the very near future. Iran is at war with Saudi Arabia, and the only way the Saudis can tip the balance back in their favour is to buy up General Motors, the company manufacturing Iran’s superior tanks. Worse still, the villainous Iran here is led by none other than the Shah

Amid Kremlin’s impotence, Ukraine increases missile attacks on Russia

Despite Moscow’s harsh threats and fearmongering rhetoric, Ukraine crossed another Russia’s “red line” and attacked […]

American Dad – On Reviving the Memory of a long lost Breed

A friend recommended Knox Goes Away (2023) shortly after I missed it in the theatres […]
- by The Liberum on 16/06/2024

Aggression in the West towards Jewish targets Channels Shame

The aggression aimed at Jewish and Israeli citizens and targets in Western cities necessitates the […]